“Soft despotism is a term coined by Alexis de Tocqueville describing the state into which a country overrun by "a network of small complicated rules" might degrade. Soft despotism is different from despotism (also called 'hard despotism') in the sense that it is not obvious to the people."

Sunday, September 06, 2009

Megrahi moved out of emergency care. More Duplicity from London.

Revealed: Libya paid for medical advice that helped Lockerbie bomber's release

The British, Scottish and Libyan governments connived to free Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi on compassionate grounds The Sunday Telegraph can disclose.

By Andrew Alderson, Chief Reporter, Robert Mendick and Damien McElroy in Tripoli
Published: 8:37PM BST 05 Sep 2009

Medical evidence that helped Megrahi, 57, to be released was paid for by the Libyan government, which encouraged three doctors to say he had only three months to live.

The life expectancy of Megrahi was crucial because, under Scottish rules, prisoners can be freed on compassionate grounds only if they are considered to have this amount of time, or less, to live.

Megrahi is suffering from terminal prostate cancer. Two of the three doctors commissioned by the Libyans provided the required three-month estimates, while the third also indicated that the prisoner had a short time to live.

This contrasted with findings of doctors in June and July who had concluded that Megrahi had up to 10 months to live, which would have prevented his release.

Professor Karol Sikora, one of the examining doctors and the medical director of CancerPartnersUK in London, told The Sunday Telegraph: “The figure of three months was suggested as being helpful [by the Libyans].

“To start with I said it was impossible to do that [give a three-month life expectancy estimate] but, when I looked at it, it looked as though it could be done – you could actually say that.” He said that he and a second doctor, a Libyan, had legitimately then estimated Megrahi’s life expectancy as “about three months”. A third doctor would say only that he had a short time to live.

This weekend it was reported that Megrahi was moved out of an emergency care unit in Tripoli.

The prognosis from the three doctors – two from Britain – was used as part of the evidence by Kenny MacAskill, the Scottish Justice Secretary, last month when he concluded that Megrahi should be released on compassionate grounds. Our investigation also reveals that:

  • Mousa Kousa, a senior Libyan politician who was expelled from Britain in 1980 for boasting of a plot to kill Libyan dissidents in London, played a key role in the talks to free Megrahi, and threatened serious consequences if the prisoner died in jail. Mr Kousa, now the Libyan foreign minister, was once implicated in planning the Lockerbie bombing – a claim he vehemently denies. According to the minutes of a meeting on Jan 22 between Libyan and Scottish officials: “Mr Kousa stated that Mr al-Megrahi’s death in Scotland would not be viewed well by the Muslims or Arabs. Nor would it be good for relations.”
  • The Scottish and British governments actively assisted Megrahi and his legal team to seek a release on compassionate grounds even though the thrust of talks before July this year had been over his release as part of a Prisoner Transfer Agreement (PTA) between Britain and Libya.
  • Senior business sources have told The Sunday Telegraph that Britain was desperate that Megrahi should not die in jail after warnings by Libya in May that if this happened trade deals between the two countries – worth billions of pounds – would be cancelled. British businessmen were also told that plans to open a London office of the Libyan Investment Authority, a sovereign fund with $136billion (£83billion) to invest, would be jeopardised if Megrahi died in jail.
  • Britain provided aid for Libya, believed to be the first since the Lockerbie bombing, when the release of Megrahi was being discussed. The £146,000 grant – which senior Tories suspect was a “sweetener” to Libya – was provided by the British Embassy in 2007-08 at the behest of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.

The revelations come after Jack Straw, the Justice Secretary, broke ranks and admitted publicly for the first time that trade and oil agreements were an essential part of the British Government’s decision to include Megrahi in the PTA with Libya. Megrahi, the only man convicted of the Lockerbie bombing of December 1988 which killed 270 people, was freed on Aug 20. His release and the jubilant scenes in Tripoli, the Libyan capital, when he returned prompted an international outcry.

Saif Gaddafi, the Libyan leader’s son, told Megrahi: “You were on the table in all commercial, oil and gas agreements that we supervised in that period. You were on the table in all British interests when it came to Libya, and I personally supervised this matter.”

After two weeks of controversy, Gordon Brown was forced to address the issue on Wednesday when he said: “There was no conspiracy, no cover-up, no double dealing, no deal on oil, no attempt to instruct Scottish ministers.”

However, the investigation by this newspaper – coupled with Mr Straw’s comments to The Daily Telegraph – cast doubts on the Prime Minister’s claims.

Mr Straw also said of Britain’s dealings over Megrahi’s release: “What we have done with the Libyans is seek to explain the circumstances in which compassionate release could take place.”

There were strong suggestions from Libya yesterday that it felt Britain had played a significant role in pressing for Megrahi’s release.

Abdul Majeed al-Dursi, the regime’s chief spokesman, said: “This is a brave and courageous decision by the British, which shows its understanding of Libyan culture by allowing a sick man to be at home when he dies.

“It showed the relations between Britain and Libya are strong and deep. We in Libya appreciate this and Britain will find it is rewarded.”

Douglas Carswell, the Conservative MP, said the latest disclosures were “outrageous” and left the British and Scottish governments facing tough new questions.

“This is further evidence that our Government has done a grubby deal with a nasty regime,” he said. “It is an oil-for-terrorist deal. The Government has always presented the medical advice as being totally objective, but it now turns out it was being paid for by Libya. It shows the Government in a poor light.”

Susan Cohen, 71, whose daughter Theodora, 20, died on the flight, said from her home in New Jersey: “It is highly distasteful that these doctors were paid for by the Libyans. Why didn’t the Scottish pay for the doctors?”

Mrs Cohen was also angered that Mr Kousa, the former Libyan terror chief, was involved in talks. “That anybody would deal with him shows how horrible this is,” she said.

Minutes of a meeting between Libyan and Scottish officials on July 6 disclose moves by the Scottish to encourage Megrahi’s legal team to apply for release on compassionate grounds.

Senior British and Scottish officials appear to have thought it was easier to justify Megrahi’s release on compassionate grounds to the Americans, who were promised that the only man convicted of the Libyan bombing would be exempt from the PTA.
The US government had wanted Megrahi to die in jail.

It has emerged in the US that the jubilant scenes that accompanied Megrahi’s return to Tripoli last month have severely jeopardised a meeting that Col Muammar Gaddafi was trying to engineer with President Barack Obama in New York later this month.

The Libyan leader had hoped for a warm embrace from the president, proving that he was no longer an international pariah. The best he can now hope for is a fleeting exchange on the edge of a UN Security Council meeting.

additional reporting by Leonard Doyle in Washington


  1. Spontaneous remission

    By the grace of God
    or somethin', but I recall predicting that the waters of Libya would be resuscitating for Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi.

  2. If he doesnt die at 90 days I advocate we shoot him in the ass....

  3. off topic

    must read on Iran

    Column One: Time's up on Iran

  4. UPDATE III. Jim Treacher:

    “So long to the lying, racebaiting, communist Truther in the White House.

    So long to a lying, racebaiting, communist Truther in the White House.

    And now maybe people will start asking how this wackjob got into the White House in the first place.

    Van, I mean.”

    Tim Blair

  5. There is simply no way he could have been working in this administration on September 11th.

    The good news for the White House: Since you made up his job, you don't have to replace him.

    Cut government waste, one czar at a time?


  6. Michelle

    Michelle, that smell
    Indicates you like to lift barbells
    Push-ups as well

    Michelle, it's swell
    You're more like monsieur than mademoiselle
    Yes, we can tell

    You're scary, you're scary, you're scary
    That's all I want to say
    Until you go away
    I will hide your human growth hormone till you understand

    Michelle, do tell
    Skynet sent you back here to raise hell
    Nice power cell

    I need to, I need to, I need to
    I need to make you pee
    Into this cup for me
    I'm telling you, it's steroid use that makes you so mean

    I fear you

    I want you, I want you, I want you
    To release my throat right now
    I'll break your grip somehow
    Until I do, I'm hanging here from your veiny hand

    Michelle, I fell
    Stomp my windpipe so I cannot yell
    It's my death knell

    And I will gasp the only words I know that you'll understand:

    Go to hell

    - Treacher

  7. OT: Think about how much room one saves in a wheeled carry-on - and more's the space for the bags of lemons and blocks of Parmigiano-Reggiano one plans on bringing back - by not packing any undergarments.

    What do they say? Half the clothes, twice the money.

    The Labor Govt's done. Cooked. Finished. And as one fine gentleman said last night, the point now is simply for those who are able to do so, to secure choice positions for themselves in the opposition. It's every man for himself.

  8. Here's hoping your custom agent shares your enthusiasm for the Parmigiano-Reggiano.

  9. I've yet to encounter any problem bringing cheese or any other foodstuffs down - and I and my husband have separately brought down pounds and pounds of it over the course of our stay. Though I have had it taken out of the bag after x-ray in Atlanta and held up incredulously by TSA folks. "Cheese. You've gotta be shitting us." "Folks, I reside in the s'marvelous but as yet culinarily impoverished land of no real Parmigiano-Reggiano. What would *you* do?"

    I think I could probably bring livestock back with me and certainly no one working arrivals would bat an eyelash. Though the driver and escort might be a little unhappy at letting it in the vehicle.