Putin's Russia will become a 'besieged fortress' as it moves towards a dictatorship
President Vladimir Putin's approval rating remained at 85 per cent in December, according to a Levada Centre poll.Photo: AFP
I hated what happened to Russia in 2014 so much that I decided to move away. It's safe to say, however, that 2015 will be worse. President Vladimir Putin's regime is one the verge of transitioning from mild authoritarianism to outright dictatorship.
The country's newly amended military doctrine is an especially ominous sign. Judging by it, the Kremlin's response to the ongoing economic crisis will be to crack down on all signs of popular discontent. The Kremlin seems determined to turn inward and complete its break with the Western world.
Russia's wariness of the West is nothing new. The 2010 edition of the country's military doctrine – issued under "liberal" President Dmitri Medvedev – listed as the top external threat the eastward expansion of NATO toward Russia's borders.
Putin's new, post-Crimea version reiterates the vision of NATO as the arch-enemy creeping up on Russia. The new doctrine differs from the old one, however, in treating domestic challenges to the ruling regime as military dangers to the nation.
Where the 2010 document merely referred to "attempts at violent change of the Russian Federation's constitutional order", the 2014 one adds "the destabilisation of the domestic political and social situation in the nation" and even "information-related activity aimed at influencing the population, primarily the country's young citizens, with the goal of undermining the historical, spiritual and patriotic traditions in the area of defending the Fatherland".
Political opposition, in other words, is now classified as an activity worthy of a military response.
This marks an important shift. Despite a gradual tightening of the screws since Putin started his third presidential term in 2012, a 13-year-old consensus had still been in effect. Protests were usually ineffectual, but often tolerated. In 2013, I took part in demonstrations that clearly violated freshly adopted restrictive laws, and, like thousands of others, escaped unscathed. There were enough uncensored media to vary one's news diet and, if you were a journalist, to write for. The economy was slowing down and growing more dependent on colossal state projects such as the Sochi Olympics. But banks weren't failing and workers weren't being laid off in droves. Moscow still emptied out for the New Year's holidays as wealthy Russians descended on European ski resorts and the tropical havens of Southeast Asia.
You wouldn't have easily mistaken Russia for a European country, but, in the big cities at least, it was still a relatively prosperous one. Then the ice cracked in the frozen kingdom, and so did the edifice underneath.
The tipping point was February 22, when Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych abandoned his sprawling Mezhihirya estate near Kiev and revolutionary crowds – and investigative journalists seeking clues on Yanukovych's corrupt rule – invaded the ornate residence. "We have no palaces," Putin said at a recent press conference, but of course he and his friends do. And as Yanukovych's home was defiled, ogled, Instagrammed and, inevitably, looted before a semblance of order was established, Putin submitted to paranoia. He mentioned the "capture" of Mezhihirya on several occasions, though the residence was, in fact, abandoned and thus lay open to all comers.
The Kremlin had always meddled in governing Ukraine, but it did so through intrigue and economic pressure, never by force.
I was glad I was not in Mezhihirya the following day as Putin asked the Russian parliament for permission to send troops to Ukraine. Overnight, Russia became a different country, roaring in unaccustomed defiance.
Putin's support quickly soared above 80 per cent, and he made an unprecedentedly regal speech, welcoming Crimea as a new Russian region. Under a 2013 law that banned "the propaganda of separatism," it became a crime to mention in public Crimea's status as an occupied part of Ukraine.
My move to Germany, however, did not mean I liked the way Western governments framed their own disapproval – by imposing economic sanctions: first, ones that were ridiculously soft, then, in July, some with a little bite. Their main effect on Putin was to persuade him, and his propaganda-brainwashed support base, that the West was intent on war with Russia, regardless of its actions. Indeed, by imposing financial restrictions, the West helped Putin forge a new political consensus: Less freedom for the sake of more national pride, expressed in the form of Russian defiance of Western pressure. The Kremlin's propagandists had plenty of time to drum this line into people's heads, using the conflict in Eastern Ukraine, in which Russian interference saved separatist rebels from a military defeat, to whip up nationalist sentiment. They also created a climate of intolerance for those who dissented: These people were now portrayed as a fifth column, working for Western masters who sought Russia's destruction.
That's why, when oil prices tumbled from $100 a barrel in September and kept falling to less than $60 a barrel, Russians did not protest against the ruble's quick devaluation and an accompanying jump in inflation, which should reach 10 per cent for the year. Putin's approval rating remained at 85 per cent in December, according to a Levada Centre poll.
Old Russia hand Chrystia Freeland, who once ran Financial Times' Moscow bureau and is now a member of the Canadian parliament, has likened today's Russia to the crumbling Soviet Union of the 1980s. "We are not dealing with a newly ascendant, domestically united world power," she wrote. "Russia today is divided and in decline."
There is some evidence to support her point of view. Between January and September, Russia lost $85.2 billion to capital flight, more than the $55.3 billion decrease in the country's international reserves in the same period, meaning Russian business has been busy cashing out.
It's not, however, Putin's billionaire friends who are voting against him with their money, as Freeland suggests. They are, quite the contrary, making out like bandits as the government awards them more and more contracts to compensate for the effect of Western sanctions. As for protest, the uptick in the relevant polls has been duly noted in the Kremlin. It could have responded by liberalising the economic climate, lowering payroll taxes, easing law enforcement agencies' malicious pressure on private enterprise. Instead, it chose to talk to potential protesters through its revised military doctrine – a dire warning if there ever was one.
Putin wants Russia to feel like a besieged fortress, and, yielding to his whip and his entreaties, the country is pupating.
That process usually ends with a butterfly breaking out of the cocoon. But that would take a bigger shock than any of Putin's enemies, including the current Western leaders, are capable of delivering. Barring a miracle, 2015 will be the year the cocoon hardens – a gloomy home to those inside and an impenetrable, unpredictable object to the outside world.
Ah, it was just a few months ago that the right-wing nutjobs were wetting their panties over the bare-chested, macho man, "real" leader, Putin.
ReplyDeleteWailing, and lamenting, they were, of being stuck with an anti-American, commie Kenyan of questionable intelligence, and allegiance.
My Lord, they exclaimed, we're stuck with this black moron, and the Roosians have "a real man. - a smart man, a chess player.!"
"What Great Things," they cried, "might we achieve if we had a man like that?"
DeleteMost of what I read by 'the right wing nut jobs' said he was a fraud, and an actor, knowing only enough to keep the vodka prices low, an immediate political benefit and long term disaster.
DeleteSpeaking of leaders:
ReplyDeleteAir strikes launched by the U.S.-led coalition has targeted a high-level meeting of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) south of the Iraqi province of Mosul Thursday night, killing 15 members of the group including senior leaders, a security source told Al Arabiya News Channel.
Meanwhile, a key ISIS leader, identified as Mohanned Salih al-Suwaidi was reportedly killed in confrontations with the Iraqi army east of Fallujah in the western province of Anbar, Al Arabiya News Channel’s correspondentin Baghdad reported.
Military security sources said the Iraqi army’s eighth brigade has halted a big ISIS attack west of Fallujah.
The U.S.-led . . . .
More Virgins, Please
South of Mosul and east and west of Fallujah.....
DeleteSouth like ISIS is trying to expand.....
Iraq top brass deeply pessimistic -
>>>al-Saadi is deeply pessimistic. In a two-hour interview with The Associated Press, he said Iraq's military lacks weapons, equipment and battle-ready troops and complained that U.S. air support was erratic. Both the military and the government remain riddled with corruption, he said. Most of the senior generals serving when the military fell apart had skills "more suited to World War II," he said.<<<
http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/iraqi-general-warns-military-woes-fighting-extremists-27960692
50,000 "ghost soldiers" are mentioned as serving in the 'Iraqi Army'.
He who would rather see the Country lose a war than see Obama win one.
DeleteOne deeply racist asshole.
One who is too stupid to wonder why a 3 Star General is leading a whopping 255 men.
DeleteA "General" who brags about going into battle not wearing the proper protective gear - thus putting unnecessary pressure on his Junior Officers, and Non-coms.
"Pupating" is good.
ReplyDeleteAn entire country pupating.......think of it !
The entire country drunk and pupating......
Russia is drinking itself to death -
Deletehttp://geography.about.com/od/obtainpopulationdata/a/russiapop.htm
>>>High Death Rate
Russia has a very high death rate of 15 deaths per 1000 people per year. This is far higher than the world's average death rate of just under 9. The death rate in the U.S. is 8 per 1000 and for the United Kingdom it's 10 per 1000. Alcohol-related deaths in Russia are very high and alcohol-related emergencies represent the bulk of emergency room visits in the country.
With this high death rate, Russian life expectancy is low - the World Health Organization estimates the life expectancy of Russian men at 59 years while women's life expectancy is considerably better at 72 years. This difference is primarily a result of high rates of alcoholism among males.<<<
Under current trends the population is predicted to drop to a little over 100,000 million by 2050.
>>>Russia's population peaked in the early 1990s (at the time of the end of the Soviet Union) with about 148 million people in the country. Today, Russia's population is approximately 143 million. The United States Census Bureau estimates that Russia's population will decline from the current 143 million to a mere 111 million by 2050, a loss of more than 30 million people and a decrease of more than 20%.
The primary causes of Russia's population decrease and loss of about 700,000 to 800,000 citizens each year are a high death rate, low birth rate, high rate of abortions, and a low level of immigration.<<<
High rate of DUI deaths too.
DeleteThere is something seriously wrong with Putin and worse yet the Russians are severely damaged as a people. That is a toxic combination. Obama would be very wise to give this feral leader a way out of the mess he has made for himself and his country and hopefully the Russians will come to their senses and replace him.
ReplyDeleteBuchanan touched on the theme that you are not going to hard ass the Russians. He is correct.
Why do people hate the Israelis?
ReplyDelete(Reuters) - Israel will withhold critical tax revenue and seek ways to bring war crimes prosecutions against Palestinian leaders in retaliation for Palestinian moves to join the International Criminal Court (ICC), Israeli officials said on Saturday.
On Friday, the Palestinians delivered documents to U.N. headquarters in New York on joining the Rome Statute of the ICC in The Hague and other global treaties with the aim of prosecuting Israelis for what they consider war crimes committed on their territory.
In a first punitive response, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu decided in consultation with senior ministers on Thursday to withhold the next monthly transfer of tax revenue, totalling some 500 million shekels ($125 million), an Israeli official said on Saturday.
The ICC was set up to try war crimes and crimes against humanity such as genocide. Israel and the United States object to unilateral approaches by the Palestinians to world bodies, saying they undermine prospects for negotiating a peaceful settlement of the decades-old Middle East conflict.
The tax revenues are critical to running the Palestinian Authority, which exercises limited self-rule, and paying public sector salaries. Israel took a similar step in December 2012, freezing revenue transfers for three months in anger at the Palestinians' launch of a campaign for recognition of statehood at the United Nations.
"This is highway robbery. Not only is this illegal, they are adding money theft to land theft. The revenues belong to the Palestinian people, they go to pay salaries and support our economy. Israel has no business deciding to steal our funds," senior Palestinian negotiator Hanan Ashrawi told Reuters.
Under interim peace deals from the 1990s, Israel collects at least $100 million a month in duties on behalf of the Palestinian Authority.
Americans do not hate Israelis.
DeleteOnly one around here who said they do, was an Israeli.
DeleteOnly one to promote 'hate' as a discussion topic, an Israeli.
It is usually part of a 'campaign' it was noted in some archeological references about Israeli attitudes, mores and behaviors.
...and as usual, the Israelis drag the US into their shit
ReplyDelete"LARGE-SCALE PROSECUTION"
In addition to the revenue freeze, an Israeli official said Israel was "weighing the possibilities for large-scale prosecution in the United States and elsewhere" of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and other senior Palestinian officials.
Israel would probably press these cases via non-governmental groups and pro-Israel legal organisations capable of filing lawsuits abroad, a second Israeli official said.
Israel sees the heads of the Palestinian Authority in the occupied West Bank as collaborators with the Islamist militant group Hamas, which dominates Gaza, because of a unity deal they forged in April, the officials said.
Netanyahu had previously warned that unilateral moves by the Palestinian Authority at the United Nations would expose its leaders to prosecution over support for Hamas, viewed by Israel and much of the West as a terrorist organisation.
Hamas "commits war crimes, shooting at civilians from civilian-populated areas", one official said, referring to the war in Gaza last summer in which more than 2,100 Palestinians and more than 70 Israelis died.
Palestinians seek a state in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem, lands Israel captured in the 1967 Middle East War.
Momentum to recognise a Palestinian state has been building since Abbas succeeded in a bid for de facto recognition at the U.N. General Assembly in 2012, which made Palestinians eligible to join the ICC.
Abbas opted to join the ICC after losing a motion last week in the U.N. Security Council to set a 2017 deadline for a Palestinian state to be established in land occupied by Israel.
The United States, Israel's main ally, supports an eventual independent Palestinian state, but has argued against unilateral moves like Friday's, saying they could damage the peace process.
Washington sends about $400 million in economic support to the Palestinians every year. Under U.S. law, that aid would be cut off if the Palestinians used membership of the ICC to press claims against Israel.
(Additional reporting by Noah Browning and Ali Sawafta in Ramallah; Writing by Allyn Fisher-Ilan; Editing by Mark Trevelyan and Kevin Liffey)
This is disgusting, really disgusting:
ReplyDeleteWashington sends about $400 million in economic support to the Palestinians every year. Under U.S. law, that aid would be cut off if the Palestinians used membership of the ICC to press claims against Israel.
AIPAC and the Israeli - firsters really controls Washington.
Fatah is its own worst enemy. Look at the photo. This is why Americans support Israel. When Palestinians become civilized during the next 16 centuries (hopefully), they may find Americans sympathetic. Until then, they will just have to get by with Europeans.
DeleteAbbas’s Fatah Movement Marks Fiftieth Anniversary With Image Inciting Genocide Against Israelis
"Their radio (media) is one long scream of hate."
DeleteMartha Gellhorn
Things haven't changed in the last 60 years....
Our Dear Leader can just use his pen and issue an executive order to change that.
ReplyDeleteI'll be happy to sit on a US jury with the Palestinians at the defense table.
ReplyDeleteParticularly if they were Gazans.
DeleteAh well, after seeing allen's post, Gazans, Fatah, it doesn't matter, all the same.
DeleteJihad Watch
ReplyDeleteExposing the role that Islamic jihad theology and ideology play in the modern global conflicts
“Moderate” Fatah posts image of huge pile of Jewish skulls
January 3, 2015 1:23 pm By Robert Spencer 21 Comments
Palestinian image of Jewish skullsGlorifying hatred, savagery, and genocide, as they have so many times in the past. Time for Obama to call on Israel to make new concessions to the “moderate” Abbas, and for the UN to issue another condemnation of…Israel.
“Outrage after Palestinian political party posts mocked up image online showing huge piles of skulls with Jewish stars of David on them,” by Jenny Stanton, Daily Mail, January 3, 2015 (thanks to Dionysios):
An image of skulls adorned with Jewish stars of David posted online by a Palestinian political party has sparked outrage.
The picture was posted on social media by Fatah, the party of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, alongside the words: ‘lingering on your skulls’.
Ofir Gendelman, the Israeli Prime Minister’s Arab media spokesman, described the image as ‘despicable’ and called into question how moderate the party is.
Maaaaaaybe not all that moderate, Gendelman
http://www.jihadwatch.org/2015/01/moderate-fatah-posts-image-of-huge-pile-of-jewish-skulls
January 4, 2015
ReplyDeletePrediction: Not enough votes to end the U.S. embargo on Cuba
By Silvio Canto, Jr.
Raúl Castro did not earn any goodwill with his speeches or arrests in Cuba since President Obama's announcement. On the contrary, Raul Castro's behavior is confirming that lifting the Cuba embargo without major concessions is very bad policy indeed.
Lifting the embargo will require 218 votes in the House and 60 in the U.S. Senate.
It will be hard, very hard, as Reuters/NY Times reported: ...................
http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2015/01/prediction_not_enough_votes_to_end_the_us_embargo_on_cuba.html
Freezing US capital and businesspeople out of a major American market, that is just not "Free Market" economics, it is Fascism.
ReplyDelete“Fascism should more appropriately be called Corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power”
Delete― Benito Mussolini
No it's not fascism. Fascism would be allowing the corporations to trade, which is what the US is going to do.
DeleteNot trading with the Cuban government - the government owns everything - denies them some means and money to keep oppressing the Cuban people. It is a moral/ethical issue. You want to support oppression in these circumstances.
You are all mixed up as usual. Thoughtless.
Which is what Obama wants the USA to do. He may not get his way.
Delete